The dark message hidden in an iconic Christmas movie

The dark message hidden in an iconic Christmas movie

The real meaning of 'A Christmas Carol'

Over the weekend, my wife and I went to the movies to see Ebenezer, the new adaptation of Charles Dickens’ classic story A Christmas Carol, starring Johnny Depp as the famously miserable Ebenezer Scrooge.

What a movie! I’ve seen several adaptations of the story over the years, but this is the best of them. The cinematography is extraordinary, the visual effects are clever and often quite confronting, and Depp is magnificent in the lead role as Scrooge.

I’m not sure whether the term ‘spoiler’ still applies to a story that was written 183 years ago but purists should be warned that the filmmakers have taken some liberties with the original story. I won’t ruin your experience by disclosing them except to say that they enhance, rather than diminish Dickens’ work

It’s an outstanding film, and I’d thoroughly recommend it.

But as I thought about it afterwards, something struck me about the story that I’d never really considered before and the more I thought about it, the more troubling it became, because buried within this beautiful Christmas tale is a message about life, death and salvation that is almost completely at odds with what the Bible actually teaches.

If you’re familiar with A Christmas Carol, you’ll know the basic story. Ebenezer Scrooge is a wealthy but deeply unpleasant man who has spent his life accumulating money while treating almost everyone around him with contempt. On Christmas Eve, he’s visited by the ghost of his former business partner, Jacob Marley, who has been condemned to wander the earth dragging the chains that he forged through his own life due to greed and selfishness.

Marley warns Scrooge that he’s heading towards the same terrible fate and tells him that he’ll be visited by three spirits during the night, representing the Past, the Present and things that are Yet to Come. Each shows him something of his life, the consequences of his behaviour and the future that awaits him if he continues down his present path.

In the new film, this warning is made particularly graphic by the appearance of other damned souls who pursue Scrooge through the streets of London. Their identity is unmistakable. These are people who lived badly and are now suffering the consequences after death. Their presence – and that of others in the movie – is intended to send Scrooge a clear message: if you change your ways, if you become kinder, more generous and more compassionate, you can escape the fate that these souls have suffered.

Which, of course, is exactly what he does. He wakes up on Christmas morning a changed man, determined to make amends for the way he’s lived. He’s generous to the poor, kind to his employees, reconciled with his family and suddenly filled with the joy of living. The audience is delighted because there’s something enormously satisfying about seeing a thoroughly unpleasant person recognise the error of his ways and become someone we’d all like to know.

But think about what the story has actually told us. Scrooge was facing punishment after death because of the way he’d lived. He was given an opportunity to change his behaviour, he took that opportunity, and as a result he escaped the punishment that would otherwise have awaited him.

In other words, he saved himself by becoming a better person. And that, whether anyone intended it or not, is a theological statement. In fact, it’s a statement about one of the most important questions any human being can ever confront: what happens to us when we die, and what must we do to avoid it?

The answer presented by Ebenezer is that we need to become better people.

The answer given by the Bible is completely different.

I’m not criticising Dickens, the filmmakers or anybody else involved in this extraordinary production. Dickens was one of the great literary figures of the nineteenth century, and he wrote a story that has entertained and inspired generations. Nor do I have any objection to its emphasis on kindness, generosity and compassion. These are wonderful qualities, and the world would undoubtedly be a better place if more people demonstrated them.

My concern is with the conclusion that people are likely to draw from the story, often without even realising they’ve been taught anything at all. Nobody goes to a Christmas movie expecting a lesson in theology. We go to be entertained, to laugh, perhaps to shed a tear, and to emerge feeling a little better about humanity – and that’s precisely what makes the underlying message so powerful. It confirms something that most people already believe, which is that if we’re fundamentally decent human beings God will somehow look favourably upon us when our time comes.

It’s a comforting thought which sounds entirely reasonable – but it isn’t what Christianity teaches.

The Apostle Paul, writing in Romans 3:10, declares that “There is none righteous, no, not one.” A few verses later, in Romans 3:23, he makes the point even more directly: “For all have sinned and come short of the glory of God.”

All. Not just people like Ebenezer Scrooge, who have spent their lives being selfish and cruel. All of us. That includes the little old lady who’s spent fifty years running cake stalls for the local church, visiting the sick, helping her neighbours and being kind to everyone she meets. We might regard her as an absolute saint, and in human terms she may well be a wonderful person. But unless she’s also recognised her need for Jesus Christ, repented of her sins and placed her faith in what He accomplished on the cross, none of those good deeds can save her.

That’s not my interpretation of Christianity. It’s what the Bible, itself, says.

Ephesians 2:8–9 puts it beyond doubt: “For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God: Not of works, lest any man should boast.”

That doesn’t mean that Christianity shuns good works – scripture is full of calls to help others. But it also makes clear that good works cannot save us. A changed life is the result of salvation, rather than the means by which we earn it.

And that’s where the message of Ebenezer becomes so troubling. Scrooge certainly becomes a better man. But if all he did was change his behaviour, he would still be a sinner in need of salvation. He could have given away every penny of his considerable fortune, fed every poor family in London and spent the remainder of his days performing extraordinary acts of kindness. None of it would have made him righteous before God.

He still needed a Saviour.

Interestingly, even Dickens himself ultimately understood this. In his will, written in 1869, he declared: “I commit my soul to the mercy of God through our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ.”

So why did he write a story that makes no mention of this essential element of salvation? The answer lies in what he was doing at around the same time he wrote A Christmas Carol. Dickens was raised in the Church of England but became closely associated with Unitarianism around the time he wrote the novella in 1843. He admired its emphasis on human improvement, charity and tolerance and these ideas are clearly reflected in the story.

The contrast is remarkable. Dickens’ died placing his hope in God’s mercy through Jesus Christ – but left behind a story that presents a man escaping punishment after death entirely through his own actions and goodness.

It’s a beautiful lie that still permeates our own culture, reinforced through films, books, television programmes, and social media – and the consequences of believing that lie are devastating and eternal. We talk about people having a good heart, doing their best, giving back to the community and making the world a better place, as though these qualities somehow establish our standing before God.

It’s a lie that doesn’t look or feel like a lie. There’s no obvious villain, no deliberate attempt to deceive and an alluring message that makes the biblical requirement for repentance and faith in Christ sound harsh, judgmental or even fundamentalist. But this is the foundational message of Christianity. It’s the reason Jesus came into the world in the first place.

We’re approaching Christmas, the annual celebration of His birth – and the entire reason for that birth was that humanity was incapable of saving itself. God sent His Son into the world because no amount of human goodness, generosity or moral improvement could ever accomplish what needed to be done.

I loved Ebenezer. I loved Scrooge’s transformation, I loved the warmth of its ending, and I think the filmmakers have produced something quite extraordinary. But make no mistake – no amount of human goodness can overcome the reality of our sin. We cannot repair our relationship with God by putting a few more dollars in a beggar’s bowl, being nicer to our relatives at Christmas or making a greater effort to help those around us.

Scrooge’s problem wasn’t simply that he needed to become a better man. His problem was the same one that confronts every one of us, regardless of how good or bad we’ve been.

He needed a Saviour.

We need to recognise that we’re sinners, repent and turn to Jesus Christ, trusting in His death on the cross and His resurrection as the basis of our salvation.

Because believing in our own inner goodness is just a beautiful lie….